Book Review: The Shack by William P. Young

09 Sep

The Shack, William P Young, William P. Young, Paul Young, William Young, The Shack book review, Christian fiction reviews, Christian fiction review, inspirational fiction reviews, inspirational fiction review, Christian novel reviews, Christian novel review, inspirational novel reviews, inspirational novel review, Christian book reviews, christian book reviewI can’t fully review this book because I couldn’t finish it. The first third of the book was incredibly painful. It was actually more painful to read that any book should ever be. It kept me awake all night with a stomach ache. I was not happy. If  you have children in your life and you’re thinking about reading this book, just be warned of what the incredible pain the main character’s experience will be to you. It’s really a horrible thing.

But that wasn’t the reason I stopped reading the book. In fact, it was the reason I kept reading so that I could hopefully feel some kind of release from all of the pain. What made me put the book down was the way God was portrayed in the book. What I had a problem with was that this encounter with God doesn’t gel with the encounters people had with God in the Bible. When God appeared to people in the Bible, they instantly were on their face in awe, feeling completely unworthy to be in his presence. This is what I was anticipating as Mack approached the shack where God was. I was picturing Job’s experience with God and others in the Bible who were honored with God’s presence. And I was very much let down. This appearance of God was nothing like that.

There were also actions and words by the three who were supposed to be God that  just didn’t settle with me. I was hoping that the images and actions of God in this work of fiction would resonate with the Holy Spirit residing in my heart. But, for me, it just wasn’t there.

Sometimes, if you get so emotionally involved in something (such as the first part of this book), you fall into a vulnerable state of mind and will be more open to consuming something that is not of God. I’m not saying this is an evil book. I’m just saying that I held it up to what I know of Scripture and what the Holy Spirit has taught me and it didn’t match up, and I couldn’t read anymore of it. (Update – since I wrote this review I found out that in 2004 the author of The Shack embraced the teaching of Universalism, which changed his entire view of God. He also wrote a 100+ page document in defense of universalism. And two of the names he used for God in The Shack come from Hinduism. So now I’m of the opinion that the book is quite dangerous to anyone who is not rock solid on their beliefs and the Word of God.)

Anything a Christian reads should be held up to Scripture and validated by the Holy Spirit in your heart. Even if it is fiction. Jesus used fiction to teach those around him many times. Fiction is important, and it’s important for Christian fiction to be biblically sound and accurate. And when it deals with something as important as God appearing to a person, it should be completely inspired by the Holy Spirit and Scripture. I feel that this book was not.


Posted by on September 9, 2010 in Fiction Reviews


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

4 responses to “Book Review: The Shack by William P. Young

  1. Sherry Carroll

    September 9, 2010 at 7:02 pm

    Vanessa, I feel the same about this book. I had heard such great things about it and was quite disappointed when I started reading it. I felt sad and depressed reading it and the portrayal of God was so off base that for that alone, I had a hard time with it. It did nothing to edify me.


  2. vanna1970

    September 10, 2010 at 9:00 am

    I’m glad someone else agrees with me. I was wondering if anyone else was feeling this way about the book. In reading some more things online about the book after I left this review, I almost feel like this book is actually a mockery of Christianity. I’m left with the feeling that Christians are being duped into believing this is a Christian book.

  3. Sarah Hills

    January 13, 2011 at 12:30 pm

    I agree wholeheartedly with how you described your review of this book! I think the pain of the situation definitely draws you in, and frankly, I think it was the author’s intention. Probably because so many people have “issues of misunderstanding” with God, and maybe even his own self (the author). I could barely stomach reading it, and thought the exact same things. It didn’t line up biblically with alot of the the encounters of God with men, it was pretty dumbed down, so to speak, and takes away the “spirit of God.” I thought at least. I could see where you could learn something from it, if you were seeking God, but it portrayed a pretty awful picture of God I thought…personal thoughts…

  4. wyolife

    February 27, 2011 at 7:52 pm

    Well, with all the marketing success of The Shack, it’s good to see some one who was able to see through all the hoopla and compare it to the Bible.

    Good for you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: